Too many new authors often give up after writing half a chapter.  They sit down thinking they’ll write the next Great American Novel on their first attempt, then quit when it doesn’t sound like Hemingway. In fifteen years of coaching, I’ve watched this happen countless times.

Here’s the reality check nobody really talks about: writing is both a gift and hard work. Some people are natural storytellers, but they still need to master the craft. Like any skill, it requires patience and persistence. Even famous authors wrote awful first drafts, but they just didn’t give up on the first attempt!

I’ve worked with many new writers through my writing coaching services, and they hit the same roadblocks. The good news? They are easy to fix once you spot them. Here are the common mistakes along with the simple fixes that actually work.

Mistake 1: Starting With the Backstory

I see this in 80% of first drafts. New writers panic that readers won’t “get” their protagonist, so they dump three pages of backstory right up front. One sentence here, a quick detail there, that’s all you need. Keep readers glued to what’s happening right now. Save the family history for later, when readers are already invested and actually want to know more.

The Fix

Drop us right into the action. Allow your character to do something on page one. If backstory is the need of the hour, weave it in later like breadcrumbs. In novel coaching, I tell my clients that instead of opening with their hometown and childhood memories, they should throw them straight into crisis. Then, when that backstory actually matters to what’s happening, drop in the detail that makes their current struggle hit harder.

Mistake 2: Trying Way Too Much

Many new authors are under the impression that using fancy words, long sentences, or metaphors stacked like a pancake will get their job done. Counterintuitive to this belief, it’s clarity that always wins. Readers are not here to gauge your vocabulary; they just won’t want things to be transported.

The Fix

The focus should always be on prioritizing clean, vivid language over complexity. As an example, if you are describing a storm, “rain hammered the roof” sounds more powerful than “precipitation cascaded in torrents upon the overhead structure.”

Mistake 3: An Overcrowded Story

When a novel tries to cover everything, it ends up weakening the story. There are too many characters and side stories, which creates chaos instead of a clear narrative. Side stories only work if they actually serve your main plot. Otherwise, you’re just adding clutter. Your readers signed up for one story, not five different ones fighting for attention.

The Fix

Identify your protagonist’s core struggle in a single sentence. Every other element should either add to that conflict or help resolve it. If it does neither, it goes.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Your Audience

It’s easier to get engrossed in telling your story so much that you completely forget someone else will one day be on the other side of the page. Remember that you are writing “for everyone” and not “just for yourself.”

The Fix

Be specific about who you are writing for. If you are targeting middle-grade fantasy, your language, themes, and pacing should reflect what captivates the attention of 8–12-year-olds. Likewise, if it is a business memoir, the writing should incorporate things that entrepreneurs grappling with similar challenges need to hear.

This doesn’t mean compromising your vision. It is all about making your vision accessible to the people who need it.

Mistake 5: Characters Without Clear Goals

Your character makes perfect sense to you because you built it from scratch. Readers don’t have that inside knowledge. If your character’s goals aren’t clear, readers will tune out fast. Your character should be chasing something specific from page one, maybe it’s finding their missing sister, getting revenge, or just surviving the zombie apocalypse.

The Fix

Within the first few pages, show your character taking action. even if it’s a small step toward their goal. If a reader can’t explain what your protagonist is trying to achieve by page 10, you need to be more direct.

Ready to Start Writing?

Pick any one of the mistakes from the above, ideally the one that made you wince with recognition, “oh no, that’s me.” Work on fixing just that one this week. And if you’re feeling overwhelmed, remember every bestseller author you admire has been exactly where you are now.

The fastest path to success is working with someone who has already walked this road before. As a published author and coach, my manuscript critique service helps writers identify what’s working, what isn’t, and how to fix it before you waste months going in circles. Book your consultation; readers are waiting! 

Posted on September 17, 2025 By
Categories: Uncategorized

No Comments

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *